Fifth Growth Pauillacs Still Solid Relative Bargains

These days you hear comments more often that wine should now show “a sense of place”. Your scribe often smiles and usually holds back on making a smug comment of “I told you so”. Having studied, tasted, and collected quality wine for over 50 years it is an important lesson so well learned. Vineyard place with unique terroir always is the key. That is why Chablis Les Clos, Meursault Perrieres, and Musigny stand above their nearby neighbours. Fond memories of discussing with the late Robert Mondavi that special site of To Kalon Vineyard that made his 1974 Reserve Napa Cabernet Sauvignon so great. There are more and more of these special “places” around the world today now making distinctive wine. In Bordeaux it is hard to go wrong with a wine bearing that textbook Pauillac AOC label. Criticize myself in hindsight sometimes for not buying more First Growth Pauillac of Lafite, Latour and Mouton during the 80s & 90s which were quite cheap then but still more money than excellent lower classed Pauillacs being collected instead. Today the First Growths are out of sight price-wise but some 5th growth Pauillacs have raised their game substantially too yet remain relatively good value. Out of the 60 odd chateaux classified in 1855 there were 18 Fifth Growths 12 of them or 2/3 from Pauillac. Today Pontet-Canet leads this select group with Lynch-Bages & Grand-Puy-Lacoste close behind with several more trying hard to make the podium. They are all making first class Pauillac wine worth investing in throughout this century.

This all came vividly back to me last week at a dinner at the Cactus Club Coal Harbour where 3 decades of Chateau Lynch-Bages held sway with the rich remarkable fruit depth of 1982, more cedar, cigar-box styling of the 1970, and leaner more medicinal mineral long distance runner 1966. These all showed still good youngish colour and surprisingly elegant complexity with a wonderful matching Beef Duo including that Short Rib Classic of celebratory chef Rob Feenie. Cactus Club Group also sports one of the world’s best sommeliers in Sebastien Le Goff who as always served these old beauties to perfection. These old vintages were outstanding value on purchase yet provided rare interesting age ability with an amazing sense of place indeed.
Do you have a favourite Fifth Growth Pauillac or a wine that shows you a real sense of place?


center


You might also like:

Ask Sid: What grapes are Pinotage?

Ask your question here

what are pinotage grapes?

Question: What grapes are Pinotage?

Answer: Pinotage is a grape variety all to itself tending towards producing a wine in a more rustic earthy distinctive style. It was developed in 1925 by a South African chemist Professor Abraham Izak Perold by crossing Pinot Noir & Cinsaut (often called Hermitage at the time – hence the name). This grape is still mainly used in South Africa either by itself or increasingly as part of so called “Cape Blends” made more interesting by being blended with other grapes. Try some.


You might also like:

William Fevre Chablis: Major Player of Consistently High Quality!

We all admire the Chardonnay (known as Beaunois) variety when grown on Kimmeridgian subsoil resulting in a special sense of place & terroir that is uniquely Chablis. The four appellations include lighter Petit Chablis (885 hectares) more on Portlandian subsoil, fresh Chablis (3370 ha), mineral Premier Cru (780 ha) of some 40 climats usually consolidated into about 17 recognized names and those 7 very special age worthy Grand Cru (110 ha).

Your scribe has been a keen follower of the William Fevre Chablis for decades. Experienced a lot of their wines during the seventies, eighties and nineties includng a period where they were being given just too much new oak that overwhelmed that remarkable terrior. That all changed in the late nineties (1998) with their acquisition by Champagne Henriot including a new winemaking team led by magical Cellar Master Didier Seguier (IWC White Winemaker of the Year 2018) still going strong 20 years later. William Fevre holds 50 hectares of this region with nearly 16 hectares of Premier Cru including 3.62 ha of arguably the best one in Vaulorent (adjoining Les Preuses). They also hold over 15% of the prestigious Grand Crus (15+ ha). Fevre has become a major player of high quality because of their consistent ability to tap into brilliantly the amazing qualities these properties are capable of showing. Always look for balance, harmony, and intensity yet capturing that special aromatic pure mineral delicacy so well. Congrats.

All of this was brought into focus on Sunday July 28, 2019 at an outstanding dinner at Nightingale Restaurant in Vancouver paired with 9 double blind white wines in 3 flights hosted by my brother Ken – a smart wine collector, star home cook, and a most talented taster in his own right of both wine & food. Fortunate to be invited to what turned out to be a surprise private tribute affair honouring Head Chef Phil Scarfone and team members including Head Sommelier Chris Rielly who both sat down to enjoy this fantastic dinner for 12 at their kitchen table. The culinary dishes chosen and well executed showed why Chef Phil so impressed the judges on the recently concluded Top Chef Canada Season 7 on the Food Network. What a tasty delicious menu!

The wines were all maturing Chablis Grand Cru (plus one wannabe or possibly shouldabe) with a 6 vintage Les Clos vertical all from William Fevre. Fun experience trying them double blind and actually nailing all as being top Chablis in my requested comments – made easier to guess correctly only because of the textbook definition of Chablis they all displayed so well. Exciting wines double decanted and served at ideal temperatures by attention to detail Sommelier Chris:

1. 2002 LES CLOS: More colour, quite an earthy open bouquet, rich full developed textures impressive. Fevre own 4.12 ha of the 26 (largest and probably best structured Grand Cru for aging) with due south slope exposure on white limestone bed. Shows that full bodied typical spicy element you often encounter with Les Clos.

2. 2004 LES CLOS: Fresh pure mineral best nose of the first flight with a racy elegant still young impression. Harmonious beauty – still improving. Killer with Prince Edward Island fresh oysters served.

3. 2006 LES CLOS: Full rich powerful excellent extract with a bit more alcohol punch. On lovely plateau to enjoy now but no rush. Perfect food wine presently- with thin crisp delightful ingredients crostino.

4. 2007 LES CLOS: First of second flight similar in style to wine #2 (2004) with lighter balanced freshness. Appreciate and admire how Fevre captured the essence of this 2007 vintage here. Brilliant winemaking. Still developing complexities but already so pure & lovely.

5. 2008 LES CLOS: Only bottle showing a slight maderization form of oxidation but not really pre-mox. Still it is full with charm underneath and quite serviceable with food – roasted mushroom pizza.

6. 2009 LES CLOS: This is different being very ripe on the nose and flavours. A big wine with more alcohol on the finish that is a result from the hot summer days of this year. Still a joy to drink in its own style.

7. 2008 VALMUR: This wine your scribe gets to try quite often. Bottle tasted last week not as pristine as this one which is so fresh. Typical power and structure of Valmur. Fevre has 1.11 ha of 13.2 with a deep clay-lime topsoil on marl with both south & southeast exposure in the shape of a small valley (“Valmur”). You have to be enthusiastic about the minerals and smooth textures here.

8. 2008 VAUDESIR: This Chablis was well liked by the group including Sommelier Chris and displayed balanced finesse with a superb mid-plate. Developing nicely. Double exposure appellation of 14.7 hectares but Fevre plots of 1.2 face only due south on very steep slopes. This Grand Cru is much richer in clay than limestone which results in an earlier drinkablility with aromas of flowers plus rounder approachability.

9. 2008 VAULORENT: Very good intense minerality here with subtlety & elegance. A little less body perhaps but top flight. Qualifies as being with the Grand Crus on the right bank of the Serein river next to Les Preuses with good drainage. Fine quality and belongs as Fevre says as their “8th Grand Cru”. Citric character is perfect match with grilled Arctic char course.
Recommend more studying of these classic Chablis treasures from William Fevre! Can appreciate them early on but they develop with age so incredibly at a better price than most other white Burgundy and with seemingly less risk of pre-mox. Enjoy.


center


You might also like:

Ask Sid: Where to visit for best wine experience?

Ask your question here

Question: I would like to organize a vacation trip in 2020 to a winery providing a significant special wine experience. Would you kindly give me a few ideas to consider?

Answer: Lucky you. Lots of countries with lots of choices. Your timing is very apt because an interesting topical list has just been released by www.worldsbestvineyards.com

They have developed a diverse Top 50 List 2019 from around the world for “the most amazing vineyard experiences” that is worth considering. Note Zuccardi from Argentina came in #1 joined by Catena at #5. Surprisingly Garzon from Uruguay was #2. Also tied for 6th were Clos Apalta & Montes both from Chile so South America has fared very well indeed. Lots of European choices and even locally Mission Hill Family Estate in the Okanagan at #50. Have fun deciding where to go.


You might also like:

Food Day Canada

Some of us keen food aficionados have been a bit peeved by the usual Canadian omission from those annual lists of The World’s Best Restaurants. Lots of different factors come into play for this result. One is the diversity of food products produced in Canada. Another is almost too many locavores and not enough focus on the national picture. This all is changing by the work done by a lot of us but brilliantly led by Anita Stewart, C.M., LLD (Hon), M.A.(Gastronomy), P.Ag (Hon) who is Food Laureate at University of Guelph with her #FoodDayCanada “Shining a Light on Canadian Cuisine”. This year will be a bigger and better celebration than ever right across Canada with red & white lights shining on @FoodDayCanada August 3. See the website map but BC Place has an early one on August 1 followed by Confederation Centre in St. John’s Newfoundland, CN Tower & St Lawrence Market in Toronto, Vancouver City Hall, BC Legislative Assembly in Victoria and so many more. In fact a Twitter Party will start things off on July 30 8-9 pm (EDT) for farmers, foodies and all of us. Join in. Recommend reading this interesting article of “Putting Canada on the Menu” with a shopping list of some 151+ “Maple Leaf on the Label” items to consider using. Canada really does have some unique and distinctively high quality products.

Your scribe attended a fantastic Food Day Canada Preview July 19 on the Wildflower Terrace at Fairmont Chateau Whistler. This dinner truly epitomized the quality that can be achieved by a skilled team using fresh local ingredients in a menu as shown here paired with Roche wines from BC. Executive Chef Isabel Chung, Executive Sous Chef Derek Bendig, Executive Pastry Chef (superb chocolatier) Anup Chaubal and their whole brigade led by Jason Gnanaprakasam Director of Food & Beverage did an outstanding culinary job with superb ingredients so artistically prepared. A bright spotlight of our top food right across Canada like this one is so appropriate. Support @FoodDayCanada please. We will make an impact on those world restaurant lists in the future.

Do you have a national food focus day like this one in your country? Chime in.

Website: fooddaycanada.ca


center


You might also like: