Ask Sid: History of Bordeaux & Burgundy?

Ask your question here The International Wine & Food Society

different history of bordeaux and burgundy

Question: When you read the history of Burgundy, inevitably it is brought up that, due to the Napoleonic Code and the change in French inheritance laws, many vineyards were broken up to the point that there are over 50 owners of, say,  Clos de Vougeot.  Sometimes owners just have two rows of vines.  My question is, why did Bordeaux escape this fate?  There are larger vineyards there, and I don’t recall ever reading about how Bordeaux estates were divided to absurdly tiny pieces of property like Burgundy.

Answer: As you indicate in your question it is really the different history of the two regions. The church and monasteries had a really big influence on the Burgundy vineyards way back to the 6th century. They later sold off their large holdings from time to time to “farmers” as smaller land parcels. However inheritance laws that were passed later divided this property between all the owner’s heirs resulting in even smaller fragmented parcels. No large investor. Bordeaux evolved quite differently with initially more wealthy owners of very large properties. More corporate orientated rather than individual owners. Rather than the property having to be split there was cash flow by selling it to their neighbours. Note that Chateau Gruaud-Larose was split into Sarget and Faure for a time but later was reunited by the Cordier family. An alternative example is Pichon was originally one estate in Pauillac but was large enough to divide into both Baron & Lalande and just carry on as two substantial properties. Also there was fresh investment by new owners (like the Chinese are doing presently) setting up large estates. A good example is Chateau Gloria not a presence in 1855 but formed during the 1940s buying up whatever available smaller parcels became available in St. Julien now resulting in a large vineyard estate of over 100 acres. Different culture and history!   


You might also like:

Whistler Cornucopia 2015 – A Celebration of Food & Drink

Whistler Cornucopia food and drink festivalPhoto Credit: WhistlerCornucopia.com

With the largest vertical drop for skiing in North America and their successful 2010 Olympic exposure Whistler Blackcomb is already world famous. Lots happening there now year round with lots of activities including trail walks, biking, hiking, mountain climbing, golf, fishing, and even more adventurous bear viewing, zip lining & bungee jumping. A great vacation destination for everyone. Also getting more attention is their annual Cornucopia celebration of food & drink the first 2 weeks of November (in 2015 from the 5th to the 15th) with details at www.whistlercornucopia.com.

Presently participating in all the fun and some of my brief highlights so far include:

Araxi Restaurant (www.toptable.ca) legendary “Big Guns” dinner organized by Neil Henderson and prepared by Chef James Walt and his talented brigade with excellent wine pairings by wine director Samantha Rahn. A typical memorable course with super matching wines: Shaved Italian Truffles + White Grace Cheese Ravioli (white & black truffles over Saltspring Island cheese pasta herb and truffle fonduto) elegant Castiglion del Bosco Brunello di Montalcino 2010 & concentrated Barone Ricasoli “Castello di Brolio” Chianti Classico Gran Selezione 2010. Watch for their exciting tapas new cellar Bar Oso opening soon. Great items such as local octopus + potato + chorizo Iberico!

BC VQA Wine Education Level 1 Seminar: A great discussion and tasting by DJ Kearney on the history (from first plantings at the Oblate Mission in Kelowna by Father Charles Pandosy in 1859 to the present expansion of over 200 wineries), the unique style of the wines, the regions, and the major grape varieties. See more at www.WineBC.org.

Black Hills Estate Winery (www.blackhillswinery.com) Nota Bene Library Vertical Tasting back to their first vintage in 1999 (all Estate grapes planted in 1996) to the impressive balanced 18th leaf 2013 vintage (Blend 49%CS, 40Merlot, 11CF with 13.7 alcohol the lowest yet for 3200 cases) with lunch in the cellar of www.bearfootbistro.com including wild pine mushroom soup porcini streusel and braised short rib. Price is $52.90 per bottle but a few special double magnums of 2013 still available for $318.80

WOW Wines seminar where we profiled many of the top wines at Cornucopia from bubbles of Ruinart Blanc de Blancs & 2007 Blue Mountain Reserve Brut RD to big cabs Signorello Estate 2012 “Padrone” (91%CS + 9CF $175 winery price) that just received a super updated Parker score of “fabulous” 97+ with “Drink it over the next 30 years”.

Crush Grand Tasting with many wineries to try from Painted Rock (www.paintedrock.ca) 2013 Red Icon to Rocca delle Macie (www.roccadellemacie.com) 2009 Roccato Toscana IDT.

Conducted with winemaker Gustav Allander a vertical Foxtrot tasting (www.foxtrotwine.com) of 10 pinot noir wines including from Henricsson Vineyard (formerly Erickson) described in Burgundian terms as a lighter “Clos des Lamprays” and the Foxtrot Vineyard (own-rooted Dijon Clone 115 planted 1994-1995) as a bigger “Clos de la Roche”. These wines indeed are sensational terroir-driven, structured, so balanced and stand up to this bold comparison.

Are 60 BC owned and operated craft breweries and brewpubs across BC represented by BC Craft Brewers Guild in grand tastings, Night Markets, Cocktail Master Mixology Classes, Culinary Stage Series featuring local and national chefs, Workshops, Lunches & Dinners, Parties, and so much more! Have you attended? Think about it for a possible November 2016 destination.


You might also like:

Thinking about visiting B.C.?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Rising British Bubbles

The rise of English sparkling wine
By Joseph Temple

Last month, a shocking upset in the world of sparkling wine took place at a blind tasting organized by the London-based magazine Noble Rot. Marking what might end up being a major shift in the bubbly balance of power, prominent champagne houses Veuve Clicquot and Tattinger were outscored by two English upstarts from Sussex and Hampshire. “This is a truly exciting time for English wine,” declared Environment Secretary Elizabeth Truss. “Not only are we beating the French with international awards but our vineyards are expanding with more people than ever before enjoying our finest British bubbly.”

But across the pond, many of us are wondering how UK wine—once considered an oxymoron—got to be so big?

While viticulture has existed on English soil since the Roman occupation, it wasn’t until the 1960s that vines were first grown commercially using mostly German methods (80% of England’s wine grapes are white wine grapes). And beyond a few eccentric vintners, Britain has usually been seen as a place to buy wine, not harvest it. That’s because quality aside, it becomes very difficult to grow a sufficient quantity of grapes anywhere north of the 50th parallel in order to stay financially viable. So how could an industry, with so many deterrents expand at such a rapid pace in such a short period of time?

The most obvious answer is the terroir of England’s southern counties, which now produce approximately two million bottles annually. Only eighty miles north of Champagne, the white, chalky limestone soils share numerous similarities with the most prominent makers of bubbly in the entire world. But even more important are the effects of climate change which now make southern England an ideal spot for sparkling wine production, turning historically thin and acidic wines into one’s that have become award winning.

With around four hundred vineyards spanning throughout every county, nearly 40% of all UK vineyards are dedicated to growing sparkling wine’s three main grapes—Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier and Chardonnay.  Harvesting these grapes, the hobbyists and amateurs of the 60s have evolved into a group of well-trained winemakers who abide by EU regulations. Author Karen MacNeil writes, “The English of course, have always loved bubbles. The country continues to be, as it has been for decades, the leading export market for Champagne. But sometimes in the 1990s, the English began to think big. Why merely bubbly? Why not try to make it?

And make it they have, with some stellar results! By adding more awards to its trophy case, English sparkling wine is primed to have its very own equivalent of 1976’s Judgment of Paris. Just as California’s wine exports took off after a whirlwind of publicity, expect to see some English bubbly on wine lists from New York to Tokyo.

Sources:

Andrews, Robert. The Rough Guide to England. New York: Penguin, 2011.
Denny, Valerie (2015, Oct. 31). English Sparkling Wine Beats Veuve Clicquot and Tattinger in Blind Taste Test. Forbes. Retrieved from Forbes.com.
Harding, Julia. The Oxford Companion to Wine. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2015.
Johnson, Hugh. Hugh Johnson’s Pocket Wine Book 2011. London: Mitchell Beazley, 2010.
MacNeil, Karen. The Wine Bible. New York: Workman Publishing, 2015.
Williams, David. Get Started: Wine Appreciation. New York: Penguin, 2013.


You might also like:

Have you ever tasted English sparkling wine?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ask Sid: Importance of the Wine Appearance in a Blind Tasting

Ask your question here The International Wine & Food Society

Importance of Wine Appearance in a Blind Tasting

Question: In a blind tasting can you learn anything from just looking at the appearance of a wine?

Answer: Good question. I rely mainly on my nose but of course also the taste. On score cards they often list lots of marks for colour and appearance but generally they are not as important as other factors.

However a few good tips to remember include:

Age – white wines get darker & red wines get lighter.
Clarity – Bright or dull, clarity, un-fined or unfiltered, throwing a deposit or sediment.
Region – usually younger yellow coloured whites (though there could be oxidation issues) and deep very dark reds are indicative from a warmer climate & a lighter colour from cooler regions (eg. Chablis).
Glycerol – The so called legs or tears are indicative of the amount of glycerol in the wine with more alcohol giving you more legs (though this can vary depending on the glass and the cleanliness of it).


You might also like:

Château Gruaud-Larose Saint Julien

Château Gruaud-Larose

In full disclosure I have been a big collector of Château Gruaud-Larose (GL) over many vintages since the sixties and know their wines quite well. After all it is a second growth Saint Julien in the 1855 Classification and generally has been very good value for the quality delivered. I liked the fact that it usually delivered a big powerful cabernet sauvignon fruit statement that developed complexity with aging. A major influencing factor for me later on was how well the harder 1870 & especially the riper superb 1865 showed against the very best wines in the world on September 23, 1985 during the historic German-American wine connoisseurs and collectors events held in San Francisco. More recently their connection with the Bordeaux styled Osoyoos Larose in the Okanagan BC was a further inducement to follow it closely. Last week our Commanderie de Bordeaux Chapitre in Vancouver held a vertical of 9 vintages of GL back to 1961 & 1966 (both in those old style shaped bottles). Some impressions:

1961: An outstanding concentrated vintage across the board in Bordeaux and GL usually among the very best if properly stored. Can rival  the stupendous 1945 & 1928. However these bottles were recently purchased at $350 US/bottle and not consistent with only 1 bottle showing that brilliant fabulous cedar cigar-box experience you expect while others were tired and oxidized with only some fading tobacco left.

1962 & 1964: Not in this vertical but recently tasted and both are still excellent.

1966: Always have enjoyed the acidity balance and long distance runner profile of this vintage. Here bottles just purchased for a bargain $100 US and showed again that providence can be everything with old wines. Still dark colour with some black currants but acidity was too high for the drying fruit and needing food to show best. I bought more bottles in January 1978 at $10.55 US and they still show better.

After 1966 GL went through a less successful period until the underrated 1981 arrived as a major surprise that is still a lovely elegant delight.  Also the underrated is 1983 certainly one of the best from the northern Medoc from a vintage that had summer rain/rot issues and favoured the Margaux & Graves regions.

1982: As I anticipated this was the wine of the tasting again this time. Buckets of ripe fruit with cassis, licorice. forest floor, cedar, complexity and no rush to open. Classy & impressive to say the least! Possibly another 1865? Pleased to have bought some in July 1986 for $115/case or $9.58 a bottle. Those were the days for the Bordeaux buyers. Sister property Château Talbot also a winner in 1982.

1985: Lighter and more of a merlot vintage for drinking now with more olives & delicacy for this property. A success.

1986: Very dark deep concentration. Lots of massive strength and potential but still needs more cellar time. Hope for another 1870?

1988: Medium colour but herbal, simpler and a bit greener.

1989: Also in this similar 1988 style of herbs and neither up to the more classic 1990. Same with Talbot.

1990: Darker with better ripe fruit and concentration. Clearly best of the last grouping from 1988 on. Will improve.

1995: Shows much younger more rustic but structured and solid. Maybe a dumb period even though at 20 years of age.

Excellent 2000 but the change in ownerships since 1997 seemed to have produced a somewhat lighter less typical from the old style that had been so successful in the very best older vintages.

My revised update assessment on the terroir of this property (located some distance away from the Gironde) is that it continues today to be a solid and reliable Saint Julien but perhaps slightly gamey with less elegant complexity and finesse so doesn’t always reach the peak of complexity shown by the First Growths or so-called Super Seconds except in the very best riper vintages like 1982 and some others.


You might also like:

Have you ever tasted wine from Château Gruaud-Larose?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...