Ask Sid: Importance of the Wine Appearance in a Blind Tasting

Ask your question here The International Wine & Food Society

Importance of Wine Appearance in a Blind Tasting

Question: In a blind tasting can you learn anything from just looking at the appearance of a wine?

Answer: Good question. I rely mainly on my nose but of course also the taste. On score cards they often list lots of marks for colour and appearance but generally they are not as important as other factors.

However a few good tips to remember include:

Age – white wines get darker & red wines get lighter.
Clarity – Bright or dull, clarity, un-fined or unfiltered, throwing a deposit or sediment.
Region – usually younger yellow coloured whites (though there could be oxidation issues) and deep very dark reds are indicative from a warmer climate & a lighter colour from cooler regions (eg. Chablis).
Glycerol – The so called legs or tears are indicative of the amount of glycerol in the wine with more alcohol giving you more legs (though this can vary depending on the glass and the cleanliness of it).


You might also like:

Château Gruaud-Larose Saint Julien

Château Gruaud-Larose

In full disclosure I have been a big collector of Château Gruaud-Larose (GL) over many vintages since the sixties and know their wines quite well. After all it is a second growth Saint Julien in the 1855 Classification and generally has been very good value for the quality delivered. I liked the fact that it usually delivered a big powerful cabernet sauvignon fruit statement that developed complexity with aging. A major influencing factor for me later on was how well the harder 1870 & especially the riper superb 1865 showed against the very best wines in the world on September 23, 1985 during the historic German-American wine connoisseurs and collectors events held in San Francisco. More recently their connection with the Bordeaux styled Osoyoos Larose in the Okanagan BC was a further inducement to follow it closely. Last week our Commanderie de Bordeaux Chapitre in Vancouver held a vertical of 9 vintages of GL back to 1961 & 1966 (both in those old style shaped bottles). Some impressions:

1961: An outstanding concentrated vintage across the board in Bordeaux and GL usually among the very best if properly stored. Can rival  the stupendous 1945 & 1928. However these bottles were recently purchased at $350 US/bottle and not consistent with only 1 bottle showing that brilliant fabulous cedar cigar-box experience you expect while others were tired and oxidized with only some fading tobacco left.

1962 & 1964: Not in this vertical but recently tasted and both are still excellent.

1966: Always have enjoyed the acidity balance and long distance runner profile of this vintage. Here bottles just purchased for a bargain $100 US and showed again that providence can be everything with old wines. Still dark colour with some black currants but acidity was too high for the drying fruit and needing food to show best. I bought more bottles in January 1978 at $10.55 US and they still show better.

After 1966 GL went through a less successful period until the underrated 1981 arrived as a major surprise that is still a lovely elegant delight.  Also the underrated is 1983 certainly one of the best from the northern Medoc from a vintage that had summer rain/rot issues and favoured the Margaux & Graves regions.

1982: As I anticipated this was the wine of the tasting again this time. Buckets of ripe fruit with cassis, licorice. forest floor, cedar, complexity and no rush to open. Classy & impressive to say the least! Possibly another 1865? Pleased to have bought some in July 1986 for $115/case or $9.58 a bottle. Those were the days for the Bordeaux buyers. Sister property Château Talbot also a winner in 1982.

1985: Lighter and more of a merlot vintage for drinking now with more olives & delicacy for this property. A success.

1986: Very dark deep concentration. Lots of massive strength and potential but still needs more cellar time. Hope for another 1870?

1988: Medium colour but herbal, simpler and a bit greener.

1989: Also in this similar 1988 style of herbs and neither up to the more classic 1990. Same with Talbot.

1990: Darker with better ripe fruit and concentration. Clearly best of the last grouping from 1988 on. Will improve.

1995: Shows much younger more rustic but structured and solid. Maybe a dumb period even though at 20 years of age.

Excellent 2000 but the change in ownerships since 1997 seemed to have produced a somewhat lighter less typical from the old style that had been so successful in the very best older vintages.

My revised update assessment on the terroir of this property (located some distance away from the Gironde) is that it continues today to be a solid and reliable Saint Julien but perhaps slightly gamey with less elegant complexity and finesse so doesn’t always reach the peak of complexity shown by the First Growths or so-called Super Seconds except in the very best riper vintages like 1982 and some others.


You might also like:

Have you ever tasted wine from Château Gruaud-Larose?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

10 interesting facts about Austrian wine

10 interesting facts about Austrian wine

By Joseph Temple

Dating back to the Celts who planted the first vines approximately 3000 years ago, Austria has a wine growing history that is rich in tradition.  During the Middle Ages, monasteries situated along the Danube River played an invaluable role by introducing pinot noir and riesling grapes to the terroir.  In fact, vineyards back then covered ten times the amount of soil that they do now.  And just like the land of Austria, its wine industry has seen many peaks and valleys, overcoming plenty of obstacles to become one of the most prestigious producers of premium wine.  Below are ten facts to keep in mind the next time you spot a bottle at your local store.


Austrian wine production

1. With an average annual yield that is less than half of Germany’s, Austria makes less than one percent of all the wine in the world – around 28 million cases per year. 75% of it is consumed locally.
blank
blank

Austrian wine grape varieties
By Roberto Verzo [CC BY 2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

2. Austrian wine law has 35 regulated grape varieties – 22 of them fall within the white wine category.
blank

blank
Austrian vineyards are located on the eastern part of the country

3. All commercial Austrian vineyards are located in the eastern part of the country, away from the Alps. Unlike most of Western Europe, the climate is known for colder winters and hotter summers.
blank
blank

Main Austrian wine regions
By No machine-readable author provided. Golbez assumed (based on copyright claims). [GFDL, CC-BY-SA-3.0 or CC BY 2.5], via Wikimedia Commons

4. The four main wine-growing regions in Austria are: Lower Austria, Burgenland, Vienna and Styria.
blank
blank

Gruener Veltliner grapes Austrian wineBy Rosenzweig (Own work (own picture)) [GFDL or CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons

5. After suffering from phylloxera and numerous harsh winters in the 19th century, an emphasis was placed on hardier grapes such as Grüner Veltliner, one of the most important varietals in Austria today – representing nearly a third of all the nation’s plantings. It produces a full-bodied and crisp wine with herbal and spicy/vegetable flavors such as green peppers, which can be excellent for food pairings.
blank
blank

White and red wine in Austria

6. While Riesling is grown mainly in the region of Lower Austria, Red wines come mostly from Burgenland, bordering on Hungary.
blank
blank

Austrian wine Danube River Wachau

7. One of the most famous wine growing valleys in Austria is Wachau, a UNESCO World Heritage Site located west of Vienna on the Danube River. Consisting of just 3,500 acres of vines, the Danube helps to moderate the climate, resulting in some excellent Riesling.
blank
blank

Austria Neusiedlersee wine

8. Austria’s best sweet wines come from near the Neusiedlersee area of Burgenland. The Neusiedlersee is a large shallow lake separating Austria from Hungary and benefits from outbreaks of noble rot, an essential component for the production of complex sweet wines.
blank
blank

Austrian wine bottling estates

9. Austria produces only a fifth as much wine as Australia – but has three times more bottling estates (6,000). The average estate covers less than seven acres.
blank

blank
Austrain wine quality since 1985 scandal

By Véronique PAGNIER (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons

10. In 1985, it was discovered that numerous Austrian wineries were adulterating their wines with diethylene glycol, giving them more body and sweetness. This resulted in a huge scandal and severely damaged the reputation of the country’s wine industry. In response, the country turned the corner by enacting vigorous quality standards.
blank
blank

Sources:

Brostrom, Geralyn G. & Brostrom, Jack. The Business of Wine: An Encyclopedia. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, 2008.
McCarthy, Ed & Ewing-Mulligan, Mary. Exploring Wine For Dummies. West Sussex: Wiley, 2011.
Parker, Robert M. & Rovani, Pierre Antoine. Parker’s Wine Buying Guide. New York: Simon & Schuster, 2002.
Rapp, Alyssa. Bottlenotes Guide to Wine: Around the World in 80 Sips. Avon: Adams Media, 2008.
Slinkard, Stacy. Idiot’s Guides: Wine. New York: Penguin Books, 2013.


You might also like:

Have you ever tasted Austrian wine?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Ask Sid: Cognac 1811 Reserve Imperatrice Josephine

Ask your question here The International Wine & Food Society

Ask Sid: Cognac 1811 Reserve Imperatrice Josephine

Question: I have two bottles of Cognac Grande Fine Champagne, 1811 Reserve, Imperatrice Josephine. Bottled in France 11/4/1934. Both bottles have leakage, one 1/2 way down the bottle, the other 1’’ from the neck. Both have damaged corks. I believe that they had been stored properly. Do you think they are still drinkable and do they have any value?

Answer: Lucky you! These are quite valuable despite the leakage issues. Once bottled Cognac won’t improve further but the high alcohol spirit will protect it against oxidation or deterioration. Josephine is named after Napoleon’s first wife and the bottles have a unique shape. One bottle of this 1811 sold at Christie’s New York about 5 years ago for over $7000. Check it out for a possible resale at auction or indulge by opening it enjoying an amazing example of the very best in Cognac.


You might also like:

Do you have a bottle somewhere that you'd like to have appraised?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Marquis D’Angerville in Volnay

angervillePhoto Credit: Marquis d’Angerville (@gdangerville)

Prices for fine Burgundy continue to climb. Lots of factors influencing this including increased world demand for a very limited supply (especially with smaller crops the last few vintages). Grand crus are very expensive and top premier crus still escalating. Encourage you to look for the best growers in less celebrated regions from Fixin and Marsannay in the northern Cote de Nuits down to Santenay and Remigny in the southern Cote de Beaune. Don’t forget the value still to be found in the Cote Chalonnaise from Rully, Mercurey, Givry and Montagny. I remain a big fan of Savigny-les-Beaune (with that smaller section of the amazing La Dominode vineyard and the larger more available Vergelesses) and Volnay. The latter appellation epitomizes what I really admire in a pinot noir showing that seductive signature of fragrant delicate elegance. In my opinion the Volnay region still remains undervalued for the quality generally delivered. A top producer is the 12 hectares of Marquis d’Angerville run by the legendary Jacques d’Angerville from 1952 to 2003 and since then by his son Guillaume and the long time experienced Renaud de Vilette. Guillaume told me the 2 key tips he received in 2003 and continues to rely on are: don’t listen to others who are acidifying & avoid over extraction to keep the freshness and reduce time in barrel by finishing off in stainless steel. My latest update visit there on April 21, 2015 impressed me with their continuing emphasis on the distinct terroir given to them by their 6 outstanding crus (they also have Mitans, Pitures and some village Volnay):

CLOS DES ANGLES: Near Pommard at the beginning of the slope with less chalk. They had .5 hectare and bought another .5 in 2007/2008 and first vintage 2009. Nose of 2013 a bit reductive.

FREMEITS: Located on the Pommard border suffered terrible hail in 2012 and late again in 2013 as well but shows the typical sturdy minerality which Guillaume described well as “eating an oyster with sea water on it”.

CAILLERETS: They had a small holding of .45 hectare but found it distinct and bought .2 more for .65 total. Quite high on the south side of the village that Guillaume describes as “sweet fruit coated with stone dust”. Still 100% destem for purer fruit. Tried their 2004 that was a tough greener vintage tainted by lady bugs that shows better with food.

CHAMPANS: Richer, structured with full plummy fruit and smoother finish from their large 4 hectare holding with low yields in 2013 of 15-16 hl/ha. Guillaume calls it “Very Volnay curvy & feminine” and “will develop some spice with age”. A freshly opened bottle of 1990 (Guillaume says he doesn’t think of decanting even though lots of sediment) had a wonderful colour in a big rich fat style typical of Champans with licorice spicy complexity.

TAILLEPIEDS: Another top cru (along with Champans, Les Caillerets, Clos des Chenes, and best sections of Les Santenots) just above Champans — has high slopes with very stony terrain that “ruin your shoes & cut your feet”. Guillaume says this cru has even more firm structure and though “austere early on it ages and lasts forever”. Always with that defining cherry fruit terroir in “exuberant years” like 2009 & 2005 but also “non-exuberant years” like 2013, 2011, 2010, and 2008.

CLOS DES DUCS: A monopole at highest elevation with old vines and unique clones on a steep limestone chalky slope with wonderful drainage that sees the first rays of sun in the morning. Peppery floral roses aromas and multi layered concentration with depth and long persistence. 2012 only in magnums. 1996 tasted with full complexity and length balanced by good acidity. Guillaume calls it a top year along with 2002, 1999, and 1990.

If you haven’t tried this producer or others from Volnay I encourage you to do so. Under appreciated and in top vintages age superbly.


You might also like:

Have you ever tasted wine from Marquis d'Angerville?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...