WHAT IS A SUPER SECOND IN BORDEAUX?

What is a super second in Bordeaux?

This used to be a much easier question to answer. Coming immediately to mind were La Mission, Leoville Las Cases, Pichon Lalande, Ducru Beaucaillou and Palmer. What about the Right Bank?

A while ago it referred to those properties that might be close to challenging for a First Growth status if an updated 1855 classification was established. In other words to join Lafite, Latour, Margaux, Haut Brion and since 1973 Mouton. Since then the so called First Growths have often been expanded to include Ausone & Cheval Blanc in St. Emilion and Petrus in Pomerol to make an Envious Eight. Remember during especially the seventies and eighties that the First Growths were not always the best wines of the vintage. A few examples: 1990 Montrose over Mouton, 1983 Pichon Lalande over Latour, 1978 Las Cases over Lafite, 1978 La Mission over Haut Brion, and 1970 Palmer over Margaux. Over the years the First Growths have effectively raised their prices by such substantial amounts that they now really separate themselves from all the other Bordeaux wines including the old Super Seconds. Moreover all of them now are doing a fantastic selection of what goes into that Grand Vin.

Today it is a very controversial question. This question became more than moot last month when we organized a BYOB Super Second dinner for our La Commanderie de Bordeaux chapitre Vancouver. It was impossible to get agreement on what properties were eligible to be brought along. I felt we should extend the new definition for the Left Bank to include Cos, Montrose, Pichon Baron, recent Pontet Canet since 1995 and older Gruaud Larose (61, 62, 64, 66, 81, 82, 83, 85, 86 and 90). Even harder to draw the line on the Right Bank. In the end it was thrown even more wide open with the Right Bank left for a 2014 event (except for a ringer of a powerful 1996 L’Evangile). Disturbing that badly corked bottles included 95 Pichon Lalande, 93 Leoville Las Cases, 1985 Ducru Beaucaillou, and 83 Pichon Lalande. However, from over 30 wines there the 1982 Pichon Lalande, 1989 Palmer, and 1990 Montrose were leading the pack just ahead of 1982 Cos, 1985 Gruaud Larose, and 1989 Pichon Lalande. Super Seconds!

Please help us determine this current definition by posting your comments.

What's your favorite Super Second Bordeaux?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Decanting Détente Diplomacy

By Joseph Temple

“This is a masterpiece,” declared Richard Nixon over the phone to Henry Kissinger.  Referring to the Prevention of Nuclear War (PNW) agreement between the United States and the Soviet Union, he and Leonid Brezhnev had just eased Cold War tensions significantly through the president’s foreign policy known as détente.  And to celebrate the historic 1973 summit that moved everyone a step closer to world peace, both leaders sipped Champagne in a brilliantly orchestrated photo-op.

It was an ironic choice since neither leader cared much for the bubbly – Nixon being a Bordeaux man and Brezhnev more at home with a bottle of Russian Vodka.  But in front of the cameras, they both drank while hundreds of invited guests applauded their diplomatic breakthrough.

President_Nixon_and_General_Secretary_Brezhnev_signing_Scientific_and_Technical_Cooperation_Agreement  Nixon and Brezhnev sip Champagne
President Nixon and Leonid Brezhnev toast with Champagne after signing a series of agreements in
the East Room of the White House on June 21st, 1973. (Photos Credit: National Archives)

All these things this week are good,” Nixon told his daughter Julie.  “It gets people thinking about something else.”

That “something else” was the Senate Watergate Committee.  With Brezhnev’s visit to the United States, all hearings had been temporarily postponed. But as soon as he left for Moscow, they were ready to go back into full-swing, starting with the explosive testimony of former White House counsel John Dean.

However, on the other side of the world, it seemed that Nixon had committed an international Saturday Night Massacre when information about the menu from his state dinner with Brezhnev crossed the Atlantic.

A “gastronomic heresy” decried L’Aurore, a Parisian newspaper.  The crime: Cabernet Sauvignon had been served with beef, a clear mismatch according to the French.  “Most assuredly, the association of a filet de boeuf bordelais with a sauvignon wine would make a gourmet faint in France.”

Adding insult to injury, the menu contained phrases in “Franglais” like “supreme of lobster en bellevue.” And calling for lobster to be served with a remoulade sauce struck the French as very odd considering it was sauce only put on celery root.

It wasn’t the first time Nixon’s wine selection created controversy.  During the first month of his presidency, he enraged domestic wine producers by uncorking a bottle of French Champagne at an official White House function.  Since the Johnson administration, only American wines were served at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue and for a Californian like Nixon to drink French wine in front of the television cameras was treasonous.

President_and_Mrs._Nixon_and_General_Secretary_Leonid_Brezhnev_of_the_Central_Committee_of_the_Communist_Party  Cabernet Wine with Beef?
(Right) The French Press was outraged at the food and wine pairings for the State Dinner honoring
Brezhnev’s visit. (Left) Brezhnev, Richard Nixon and First Lady Pat Nixon attending the dinner.

But was it French pride over all things food and wine that caused this cause célèbre?  Or was there a more conspiratorial motive for blasting this White House selection?  One American newspaper hypothesized:

“We all know that West European countries fear their influence in world affairs will diminish as the United States develops closer ties with China and the Soviet Union.  Now supposed that Brezhnev became convinced that Nixon had served him an inappropriate wine.  That surely would be a a major setback in the effort to improve relations between the two countries.  At the same time, it would enhance the prestige of France – making it appear that French advice on wine selection is indispensable to the conduct of American foreign policy.”

Whether it was a well orchestrated plot by the French government to derail Nixon’s policy of détente or not, a few journalists did rush to the president’s defense.  “I don’t know whether Nixon was exquisite in serving a Cabernet with beef because I never tried the combination,” wrote syndicated columnist Andrew Tully. “Palates differ … you can advise an American on wine, but never, never a Frenchman.”

So what do you think of this little Cold War footnote?  Successful gastronomic experimentation or colossal failure?

Cabernet with beef?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

SPARKLING WINE (including Champagne)

sparkling wine including champagne

Welcome to December including the festive season of Christmas and New Year’s Eve when the most sparkling wine is consumed. So many choices to make including value driven Spanish Cava, increasingly popular Italian Prosecco, Sekt from Germany, Austria and Czech Republic, Cap Classique from South Africa, and emerging cooler regions like England (Nyetimber), Nova Scotia (the remarkable Benjamin Bridge), Ontario (the limestone soils of Niagara & Prince Edward County – check out 13th Street Winery), and British Columbia (Blue Mountain & Road 13 old vines Chenin Blanc). So many states in the USA, Australia, New Zealand, Portugal and others also in the mix for bubbles.

Everyone is making their annual choices now to guide you including this scribe. See www.vancouversun.com/life/Sparklers+froth+over/9200754/story.html

Champagne still has to be highly respected. So many Growers’ Champagnes now available. The category has exploded since Philippe Boucheron published his excellent Monograph for IWFS in 2000 saying they “have not enjoyed the recognition they deserve”. I am fortunate to personally drink with pleasure rather frequently his referenced Pierre Gimonnet (Cuis), Diebolt-Vallois (Cramant), Jacques Selosse (Avize), Larmandier-Bernier (Vertus), Alain Robert (Le Mesnil-sur-Oger), Gaston Chiquet (Dizy), and Vilmart (Rilly-la-Montagne). Time for a revised update!

I love Krug, Salon, Pol Roger, Dom Perignon, Roederer Cristal, Bollinger, Gosset, Jacquesson and so many more houses. I try to imitate the stylish choices of James Bond whenever I can.

Still a soft spot for Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin since I was inducted in Reims by Edouard de Nazelle on May 27, 1997 into their honoured circle of “Cercle Des Amis De La Veuve” (Friends of the Widow). Met recently in Vancouver with their Chef de Cave Dominique Demarville (for nearly 4 years now following the renowned Jacques Peters) who indicated that 2012 shows concentration from smalller yields of 9500 kilos/hectare (30% less than average) with balanced 8.6 high acidity. The weight, body, and structure of pinot noir shines through in 2012. Chardonnay better in 2013. Sipped the elegant full of finesse 2008 La Grande Dame (61% pinot noir & 39% chardonnay) in their brand new special shaped thin rimmed larger glass and Dominique indicated to me that the next ones would have increasing amounts of pinot noir in the blend. The new 2008 vintage VCP (but not LGD) was 10-15% in older larger oak (55 & 75 hectolitre size) purchased in 2007. Always looking for improvements though the successful NV Carte Jaune Brut remains the same fine quality.

What sparkling are you drinking this month? Do you have a favourite Grower Champagne? Vote now for the Champagne you enjoy!

Favorite Champagne or Sparkling Wine?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Cuisine à la Camelot, 1961

cuisinealacamelot

By Joseph Temple

On the same day Americans were summoned to ‘ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country’, John Fitzgerald Kennedy sat down for his first meal as 35th President of the United States.  After starters of creamy tomato soup and deviled crab meat Imperial, the next course catered specifically to the new Executive Branch of JFK and LBJ: New England boiled stuff lobster with drawn butter and prime Texas ribs of beef au jus.

This was the beginning of Cuisine à la Camelot.

For a thousand days, 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue became the epicenter for lavish state dinners and meals that symbolized early 1960s enthusiasm.  Historian Marie Smith in her 1967 book Entertaining in the White House writes, “Not since the days of Dolley Madison had the White House been the scene for such brilliant entertaining as was done by First Lady Jacqueline Kennedy and her history-conscious husband, John F. Kennedy – and not since the days of Thomas Jefferson, America’s first gourmet of renown, had more serious thought been given to White House standards of food and drink.”

Julia_Child_at_KUHT  Mastering-the-Art-of-French-Cooking  Dom-Perignon-Moonraker-Bond  DSCF6173
INFLUENCES: Julia Child (left), the world’s first “celebrity chef” popularized French cuisine with her cookbook Mastering the Art of French Cooking (2nd from left). Spy James Bond drinks Dom Pérignon ’46 in the 1955 novel Moonraker (2nd from right).  Kennedy was a huge fan of author Ian Flemming and his 007 character, who debuted on the big screen in 1962’s Dr. No where Sean Connery’s character tells his captor after trying to break a bottle of Dom Pérignon ’55 over a guard’s head “I prefer the ’53 myself.” (right)

It was 1961 and Julia Child was at the height of her popularity after releasing volume one of Mastering the Art of French Cooking.  Anything French was distinctly fashionable throughout American culinary circles.  So it is no surprise that many dishes served to the Kennedys and their guests paid tribute to White House Chef René Verdon’s Parisian roots.  With casseroles of the 1950s clearly out-of-style and the ration books of the 1940s a distant memory, the new  administration was a clear shift from the previous era symbolized by Truman and Eisenhower.

Chef Verdon took over an operation previously run by caterers and Navy stewards not known for producing quality dishes and transformed it into the modern White House kitchens we know today.  Promoting local fresh foods before it became fashionable, his kitchen staff cemented the Kennedys as hip culinary trend setters  – resulting in many suburban housewives making soufflés, pâtés, and pork rillettes for their own dinner parties.

Debuting with trout cooked in Chablis, roast fillet of beef au jus, and artichoke bottoms Beaucaire, Chef Verdon’s meal for JFK and British Prime Minister Harold MacMillan made the front-page of the New York Times, prompting Craig Claiborne to write, “there was nothing like French cooking to promote good Anglo-American relations.”

For the visit of Korean General Chung Hee Park, a lunch that can be described as classical upscale French cuisine meets Southern style cooking was served.  It featured snails in brown butter parsley sauce, barbecue chicken, potatoes, and creamy mushrooms.  A simple yet elegant lunch filled with the charming rustic touches of an open grill.

White House Chefs  3b36339r  026402pv
(Left) White House Executive Chef René Verdon (third from left) and members of the White House kitchen staff pose with an assortment of cookies. The kitchen went through numerous renovations in the 20th Century.  The kitchen in 1901 (middle) and in the 1950s (right).

And during most of 1961, the Kennedys drank almost exclusively French Wine and Champagne.  An example wine menu from the 1961 White House gala in honor of former President Harry Truman: 1955 Château Gruaud-Larose – an underrated vintage of pure cedary Cabernet second growth, St. Julien styling, 1958 Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles – a Chardonnay with pronounced notes of creamy buttered apples, and 1952 Cuvée Dom Pérignon Brut.

It is no surprise that Jack Kennedy loved Dom — the same drink consumed by a fictional spy named James Bond in the Ian Flemming novels that the  president devoured.  And while Agent 007 preferred a ’53, the 1952 served at the White House was a long aging firm rich year when there was still some barrel fermentation for complexity.

In an era before Twitter, cell phone cameras, and a tabloid media, the press largely complied with the Kennedys’ request that the wine list from White House functions not be printed in the next day’s  newspapers.  However, when word began to leak that no American wines were being consumed, public pressure convinced them to start serving wine from the United States and more specifically California – a region that hadn’t yet exploded into the mainstream.

“We served only French wines in the beginning,” recalled Kennedy White House social secretary Letitia Baldrige.  “But about six months into the Administration there was such a hue and cry about it that we began to serve mostly American. We would serve one good French – either a wine or Champagne – but the other two wines would be American. And sometimes we would serve an Italian wine such as a Soave Bertani.”

At the table with his guests however, Kennedy was not always on top of his game in terms of dinner diplomacy. When Monaco’s Prince Rainier III and his movie star wife Grace Kelly stopped by in 1961, the president worried about mispronouncing his name “Prince Reindeer.”  Months earlier, he had enraged Canadian Prime Minister John Diefenbaker when at the White House, he called him in front of the entire press corps “Prime Minister Dee-fen-bawker.”  He did not want an incident like that to occur again.

17713_0092_1_lg  JFKWHP-KN-C17889 Grace Kelly White House visit meeting John F. Kennedy
(Left, Middle) Prince Rainier III and Princess Grace of Monaco Arrive at White House for a Luncheon in Their Honor. (Right) The menu for their visit.

But as they enjoyed their light lunch of Salade Mimosa, Soft Shell Crab Amandine, and Spring Lamb à La Broche Aux Primeurs, JFK accidentally responded to the Prince with “Prince Reindeer” in his signature Bostonian accent.  Thankfully, the gaffe was short-lived when in an interview four years later, the Princess recalled every detail of the lunch including all the dishes she had eat – a clear sign of success for Kennedy’s kitchen staff!

Away from Washington, JFK and Jackie were treated to an impressive feast at Buckingham Palace.  It was 5 June 1961 and a little over a month since the disastrous Bay of Pigs invasion.  The previous day in Vienna, Kennedy had stared down Nikita Khrushchev in a high-stakes game of nuclear diplomacy over Berlin – setting the stage for future confrontations in 1962.  So with Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip by his side, the president ended his European charm offensive by enjoying some very royal dishes.

John F Kennedy and Queen Elizabeth, 1961 Menu for JFK's visit to Buckingham Palace
(Left) Prince Philip, Jacqueline Kennedy, Queen Elizabeth and JFK pose for a photo at Buckingham Palace.  (Right) The menu from that event.

Beginning with creamy pea soup, hollandaise sole garnished with asparagus second, lamb and buttered green beans was served as the main course.  This seemingly simple menu would have been masterfully executed with classic French techniques to impress Her Majesty and guests.  Not only did the many refined sauces showcased make precision timing critical, the showstopping Grand Marnier soufflé served for dessert is one of the most difficult dishes to execute for such an expecting crowd.

Clearly, 1961 served as transformational year for food and wine served in the White House; 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue was now on the cutting edge of the culinary arts.  An exclusive team of superb cooks, headed by a French chef, would shape food and wine served even today to the modern Presidency.

Please have a look at the pictures and menus on this page by clicking to enlarge them.  Also, vote for what you think is the best dish served during this year and leave your comments.  Special thanks to Sid Cross who helped to provide information on the wines.

JFK Inauguration Luncheon MenuPresidential Dinner MenuJFKPP-043-037-p0003

What dish would you like to recreate from this article?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

SEAFOOD CHOWDER CHOWDOWN

Seafood Chowder

Judged on November 20, 2013 the 6th Annual Ocean Wise Seafood Chowder Chowdown for this popular fundraiser at the Vancouver Aquarium (www.vanaqua.org) to support their continuing fight for sustainable seafood (www.oceanwise.ca). Blogged earlier in my May 27 posting about the wonderful work being done by Ocean Wise. Lots of recipes were submitted by British Columbia restaurants and after some earlier preliminaries a select 13 entries arrived for the finals to be judged by us and the 600+ enthusiastic patrons. Each was paired with a unique craft beer chosen by the chef to complement their dish. The People’s Choice vote was won by Chef Ned Bell of Yew in the Four Seasons Hotel using humpback shrimp, all local cranberries, hazelnuts, apple relish, corn, purple cauliflower in a base of pink peppercorn 35% cream. Winning the judge’s vote for the second consecutive year was Chef Chris Whittaker of Forage with an exact repeat encore of his very successful menu item of Creamy BC Spot Prawn Chowder. Many chefs utilized in the mix some of our great Dungeness Crab even serving it in the empty crab shell – and of course lots of clams and clam nectar. Surprised so many chefs still feel the need to use flour or potato starch to thicken.

Lots of questions raised again by me during the judging as to what is required to make an outstanding chowder. Certainly in this criteria were some of our scoring items of clean delicious taste, aroma, appearance, presentation, creativity, prep & delivery (warm, seafood intact, good textures), beer pairing (Chablis or crisp Sauvignon Blanc also would have worked well with many of the chowders except the spicier ones which needed Gewurztraminer). Every year sees submissions of over 90% creamy New England style and hardly any tomato-based Manhattan styles. One bowl of rich creamy chowder can be satisfying but when you are trying so many in a row your palate really appreciates the change-up of a more refreshing tomato character – and in previous years even tomatillos!

Please give us your wisdom on what makes for you a great chowder. Vote whether you prefer New England vs. Manhattan – not a football match!

What chowder do you prefer?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...