How best to select wines to pair with food courses is a source of many opinions and much debate. Recommendations have evolved because of the high cost of traditional wine pairings plus the now available interesting wide selection of quality wines from around the world. Many diners prefer at dinner simplifying the presentation to just one wine to enjoy with the dish served emphasizing more social interaction. Wine groups sometimes organize an event with a wine theme resulting in an educational tasting of many wines at either a vertical or horizontal. Another fine choice is the mini vertical or horizontal allowing the diner to study and compare two or three similar wines. The Sous-Commanderie de Vancouver of Confrerie des Chevaliers du Tastevin has brilliantly achieved this at two consecutive events. Kudos for most smartly chosen wines by new Grande Senechale Dr. Christine Collison and Cellarmaster Blair Curtis at both the annual wine & cheese soiree (reported last year on March 18, 2024 here) on March 5, 2025 and Tavola restaurant combining French wines with Italian cuisine on April 8, 2025.
Your scribe really appreciated the opportunity to experience the vintage variations of the same wine. A few comments:
At Wine & 16 Cheeses:
MEURSAULT PERRIERES 1ER CRU ALBERT GRIVAULT 2006, 2008, 2015:
Really like the complexity and aging ability of this excellent vineyard – especially in 2014. Here instructional to compare hotter year 2015 at higher 14 abv with less acidity but full rich extract opulent style drinking forwardly but no rush – seems more like the rounded power of Charmes; Cooler 2008 smaller pour as one bottle was maderized showing best with lighter elegance better balanced acidity with subtle minerals almost Genevrieres in style; Exotic 2006 more maturity with tertiary complex bouquet with richer depth on best plateau now.
CLOS VOUGEOT GRAND CRU of different producers from 3 vintages:
Not top vintages but all showed better than expected approaching best plateau for current enjoyment.
2007 DOMAINE GROS FRERE ET SOEUR “MUSIGNI”:
Variable year but lovely clean elegant and stylish from a key vineyard north of the Chateau with major mid-1980s replanting.
2006 ALAIN HUDELOT-NOELLAT:
Vintage that required careful sorting because of rot. But here with a property south of the Chateau shows the darkest biggest solid most fruit of these three. No outstanding 2005 in this flight but this surprises evolving rather nicely with balance.
2004 DOMINIQUE LAURENT:
Controversial “lady-bug” year often with those flawed green vegetal notes but wine better than many 2004 red Burgundy. Lacks ripe fruit and finishes rather dry but OK with food.
At Tavola excellent Italian dinner by Chef Wesley Weber and brigade:
Underated Vaulorent vying with Montee de Tonnerre for best 1er Cru Chablis. At southern end of large 130 hectare Fourchaume are 13+ hectares of Vaulorent adjoining Grand Cru Les Preuses. A rich full complex Chablis especially from William Fevre.
2008 CHABLIS VAULORENT 1ER CRU DOMAINE WILLIAM FEVRE:
All their Fourchaume vineyards are in the prized Vaulorent section. Shows lightest youngest green tinged look. Wonderful fresh minerals and vibrant lift. Could be a bit fuller perhaps but excellent typicity. Clear winner!
2009 CHABLIS VAULORENT 1ER CRU JEAN-MARC BROCARD:
Dark yellow golden look from hot year. Very mature. Rich ready soft lacking needed acidity. Drink up.
2015 CHABLIS VAULORENT 1ER CRU DOMAINE LOUIS MICHEL:
Top producer since 1850 but hot year has advanced dark look with the opulence of Vaulorent but more “Macon-like” fruit.
Shows you to collect for aging the better balanced vintages like 2010, 2014, 2017, and 2020.
POMMARD LES GRANDS EPENOTS 1ER CRU DOMAINE MICHEL GAUNOUX 1999, 2001, 2002
Misleading names like in Echezeaux & Grands Echezeaux. Here Les Grands Epenots is smaller than Les Petits Epenots and refers to the grander longer length of the vine rows.The most elegant Pommard is between the two as the monopole of Comte Armand in Clos des Epeneaux. Wines show their vintages well here from the largest holdings of Domaine Michel Gaunoux.
1999: Darkest deep look. Dense concentrated fine tannins. Intense age worthy and very Pommard. Patience.
2001: Less ripeness. Lighter colour open & developed at 24 years. Easy current drinking now.
2002: Consistent surprising year. Like the elegance and charm of the red cherries fruit.
2000 NICOLAS POTEL – Compare same vintage and producer who picked later in 2000 from different vineyards:
CHAPELLE-CHAMBERTIN: Does better in cooler years (opposite of Latricieres). Pretty clean without rot but less acidity than some 2000s with earthy softer and supple textures.
MAZIS-CHAMBERTIN: Way more fruit depth and rich complexity of this vineyard shows through. Prefer the structure and the power of Mazis.
Thanks for the experiences.
You might also like:
 |
 |
 |